Rate this Article
Does the Muslim World Know the True American
Reaction to the Iraq Abuse
By Abdul Malik Mujahid
It was at the height of the
Watergate scandal during President Richard Nixon's presidency in 1975
when, after his return from America, Syed Abulala Maudoodi spoke
at Karachi University praising American democracy. The reaction of America
towards the abuse in Iraq reminded me of his comments almost 30 years
ago. What impressed Maudoodi, the most prominent Islamic scholar and
the foremost Muslim critic of the West in the last 50 years, was the
free press and the system of checks and balances of American democracy
which he observed during the Watergate scandal during his stay in the
America's reaction to the torturous sexual
abuse of Iraqi prisoners of war is a sign of a nation living its ideals.
Although they are reacting to something extremely abhorrent and horrible,
it gives me confidence in humanity and in America.
Yes. They were soldiers of the American occupying army who did the
most horrific things to Iraqi prisoners. But what the Muslim world also
needs to know is how America is reacting to it.
Seventy-three percent of Americans surveyed say Iraqi abuse was unjustified.
organizations in American are speaking out. Everyone who matters
in America is showing their displeasure over the images and asking for
the understanding of the Muslim world. They want to make it clear that
these are isolated cases and America is not like that. It reminds me
of the aftermath of 9/11 when Muslims were trying their best to explain
that the 19 hijackers were not representatives of Islam or Muslims.
Maybe the super-humbling experience of a super-power will allow it to
understand the pain Muslims have gone through paying for those 19 hijackers'
acts of terrorism.
Let's see how some of the important institutions
in America are reacting to the Iraqi prison abuse tragedy.
The American media has not been as free and
independent lately as the European media. But one cannot much complain
about the coverage of the Iraqi abuse.
- It was an American network, CBS, who broadcast
the photos that outraged the world.
- Almost all media has been repeatedly reporting
the abuse. No one is trying to hide something that can clearly hurt
American national pride.
- Many media outlets have published the extremely
damaging, still classified, Taguba Report.
- Almost all editorials and op-ed page writers
have condemned the abuse in the strongest possible terms.
- The media continues to disseminate follow-up
stories on the issue.
- The media is regularly reporting the public's
- A few talk show hosts who took the abuse lightly
are being criticized.
- A few stories are connecting the Iraqi abuse
tragedy to the sexual attacks on female American soldiers by fellow
male soldiers in Afghanistan and Iraq.
- Other media reports are suggesting abuse in
Iraq is similar to prisoner abuse in the US.
- Now the award-winning journalist Seymour M.
Hersh has written that the abuse of Iraqi prisoners was a result of
the policy approved by the Secretary of Defense.
- The government advertisement were not withdrawn
from any newspaper for reporting the classified, General Taguba Report.
- No writer, editor or correspondent has been
picked up by any intelligence or military agency to date for writing
hostile stories against US military interests.
- The US government has not banned any newspaper,
TV channel or radio station due to the negative coverage that is causing
the president's ratings to decline.
Executive and the Legislative Leadership:
Republicans and Democrats, Executive and
Legislative branches of the government have all have been vocal in condemning
- The Senate has condemned it with 98 votes.
- The House has also approved 365-to-50 a resolution
that "deplores and condemns" the abuse of Iraqi prisoners.
- Republicans and Democrats are both being given
equal time to raise questions and read their comments, although Republicans
have a majority.
- President Bush and almost everyone in the executive
branch have condemned it.
- The military and general after general, have
been publicly answering questions about this issue. This is significant
because at a time of war, they are answering to the civilian leadership
instead of using the ongoing situation in Iraq as an excuse to refuse
to answer allegations.
- The executive branch has made it public that
there are more horrific pictures of abuse in existence and they are
being shown to the Senate and the House.
- Although some Senators are outraged over the
', all has been a civil discourse.
- By the way, no outspoken Democrats were arrested
after the hearing outside the Hill by the President's secret service.
- The Senate is conducting a public hearing about
the abuse live in front of cameras and via live broadcasts, where
army generals and their civilian leaders are being questioned. Transcripts
are available on the Internet.
- The House is doing the same.
- Major questions are being raised about the
executive's openness on this issue.
- The main questions being asked deal with the
issue of who else knew the abuse was going and when, and whether Abu
Ghraib is an isolated case or a reflection of a systemic problem.
The Military Response:
This is the institution facing tremendous stress. Let us see how the
institution is performing under the extraordinary pressure
of the media, politicians, and the public besides fighting insurgencies
in Iraq and Afghanistan:
- It was an honorable
American soldier from Pennsylvania who brought the abuse to the
attention of investigators. On January 13, 2004, Army Spc. Joseph
M. Darby, an MP with the 800th at Abu Ghraib, first reported cases
of abuse at the prison. He is being praised by almost everyone in
- The military officer who received the complaint
did not sit on it. Within a day an investigation was launched by the
- Several soldiers were suspended from their
duties before the images went public.
- Several soldiers are now facing court marshals.
- Military and civilian attorneys are available
for soldiers to defend themselves in the court martial. In addition,
the accused soldiers are issuing statements to the media saying that
they were following orders when they engaged in the abuse of the Iraqi
- It was an American General, Antonio Taguba,
who wrote the most damaging report to date on the abuses. He is being
praised instead of being admonished.
- There are more than 20 investigations in place.
- Individual soldiers returning from Iraq are
openly commenting about the cases
of abuse in Iraq.
- The commanding general of Iraqi prisons where
the abuse occurred, Brigadier
General Janis Karpinski was was given a letter of admonishment
for the abuse.
- No secret agency is kidnapping any reporter
for reporting against the interests of the American military.
- The Military Chief of Staff has not threatened
to take over the country if criticism of the armed forces does not
This is the time for the Muslim world to
stop watching Hollywood movies and see how America is handling a moral
crisis involving abuse of their imprisoned enemies.
No it is not a perfect system. No human system
can be perfect since we are not perfect. Of course, not everything is
fine and good. There are many questions that have to be answered. But
all of them are being asked by the media and leaders openly and publicly.
If you have any questions just raise them now. All media, senators,
congresspersons' contact information is available right on the Internet.
In case some cynic declares that all of this
is being done to please the Muslim world, I would say maybe there is
a bit of truth to that. But if America cared for world public opinion,
they may not have invaded Iraq to begin with. This moral outrage is
not a fake show, it's the true reflection of how America is feeling
at this moment. This is democracy at its best.
Yes. I believe the American attack on Iraq was unjust. I have
been writing about it and have spoken against it in rallies as millions
of other Americans believe and speak against it. When the war began,
we were a minority. Now a majority believes that it was wrong to attack
Yes. There are many areas of concern regarding
this scandal, some of which you can find in my article regarding the
of Muslims in America. However, please also note that all references
in that article are themselves gleaned mostly from the American media
itself which is open to report on these issues.
But the point is, this is the beauty of an
open society, a free media, freedom of speech and democracy. I wish
Egyptian papers could write about the torture in Egypt as much as American
papers can. I wish Saudi Arabian people could also demonstrate the outrage
they feel about the daily rape of Sri Lankan and Filipino maids working
in the homes of Saudi Arabia.
When Muslim societies are as committed to
free press, free speech and democracy as we are to Islam, Muslims will
be on a better ground to challenge the "immorality" of America.
If Muslims love the ideals of liberty, justice, peace, and fairness
we believe existed at the time of the Prophet and the rightly guided
caliphs, and would like these values to become the dominant traits of
Muslim societies today, then it cannot be done without the free press,
due process, and democracy.
If media in the Muslim world can generate
even one-tenth of the moral outrage shown by American society at this
moment regarding the torture and violation of human rights in Muslim
countries, we will be on our way towards a better world.
Robert Williams, Cuyahoga Falls, Ohio -
wrote on 9/26/2004 2:47:00 PM
Comment: ASAK. Last month, August, my wife and I visited the Lorain County Fair in Wellington, Ohio. As we entered the fairgrounds through its east entrance, we passed by an Army recruitment booth. The young soldier manning the booth was engaged in coversation with some young Americans. After we walked passed him, I turned to see him pointing his rifle at us while he looked at his friends and said "Allahu Akbar". I told my wife what happened and she wanted to confront the young soldier, but I didn't want her shot so we kept on walking. A similar thing happened at the Eurotrain station in Paris: a young Uzi-carrying soldier made a pelvic thrust at my wife who was several yards ahead of me as we tried to catch the train that we missed anyway. When he realized that I was with her, he turned away. My wife wears a Libyan-styled hijab, even though she is British Indian. So soldiers, whether American or French, mistake her for an Arab or correctly take her for Muslim. These two cases bring me to my point: the military is brainwashing these soldiers that the enemy is no longer the Commies as I was brainwashed nearly 25 years ago; the new enemy is Muslims. This brainwashing has been going on for over a decade, since the first Gulf War. They teach that Muslims are not people, their hearts have no compassion, they lack feelings, they strap bombs to their children for suicide attacks, etc. The dehumanizing of Muslim people equates them with animals; the British did the same against the Irish, referring to them as "white apes". Americans kill animals regularly, from road kills on the public highways to hunting for sport. So killing animals is something that doesn't upset a majority.
As long as the military brainwashes its members to hate Muslims and Arabs, they are responsible for the atrocities committed by them. This attitude is complained of by Christian Arabs as well as Muslims.
Steve, USA -
wrote on 9/24/2004 2:59:29 PM
Comment: Being an average american, I think this article was well written and hits the mark on what the majority of americans believe in. However I do take offense at some of the posts. I, as an american before Sept 11 did not think about muslims good or bad. They did not affect my life. Now I read and hear through forums like this or through the media how the world and muslims accuse americans of being anti muslim. How we plot your demise and purposfully pick on you for your religious beliefs. I as an average american could distinguish the radical actions of the 19 hi jackers and regular muslims and I held no animosity toward YOU. But all the negative responses shown here in this forum and abroad about americans has led me to think more about muslims and the more I hear the more I dont care what happens to YOU. I believe this sentiment is spreading, we were attacked, we responded to a threat that claimed to be muslim, we continue to respond to the threat of terrorism and try to prevent it. If the MUSLIMS didnt want our interference in Afg. and Iraq maybe they should have left us alone. When you poke a big bee nest you get stung. To finish up in the words of a great man "BRING IT ON". I know you wont post this on your site because talking about free press and actually doing it are two diff things.
Karema, Los Angeles -
wrote on 9/2/2004 2:13:49 AM
Comment: I am a person that listens to many different talk radio shows, (right-wing conservative), based on the feed-back from people that call in, based on the silent Christian Community, print & TV media, I would have strongly disagree with the writer. Many American are outraged over the prison scandal, but not enough. Had the story been turned the other way, and it was Americans being abused in this way, the self righteous indignations would never end. What happen with the Geneva Convention? It went right out the window. Again I ask Americans to just imagine for one moment what the out cry would have been had American soldiers been photographed naked and worst. It is hard to look at ourselves in the mirrow and admit we are the the righteous people we claim to be in the world.
muslim, duniya -
wrote on 8/21/2004 1:36:19 AM
Comment: This articles seems like nothing more than bootlickers sucking up. The US media showed that stuff AFTER rest of the world had seen the pictures already and ALREADY knew of the abuse. Since the world knew already, so people here had to act to pretend to hate it to show face. The example of the 19 hijackers is nothing like this... they did that on their own (if they did it...) where as this was done by the government telling it's soldiers and to do it and providing the training and equipment.
Shakil, Manchester, UK -
wrote on 6/23/2004 11:41:22 AM
Comment: Im sorry but the article written was in no way any consolation to myself and i suspect any of the abused at abuGraib or Afghanistan. As we are learning today through the few media reports that are coming through some of these actions were condoned and even recommended by the government of the US i.e. use of dogs in "interrogation" of inmates in Afganistan was specifically endorsed by Donald Rumsfeld. And with regards to the medis in America it aided and abetted the lies that were told to the nation in justification of the war. i.e New york times CNN etc. We over in europe got some sort of impartiality but even that was far from balanced. I also don't think we should be using the illigetimate puppet governments of the Middle East as a bechmark/yardstick for measuring the western democracy or media against. It's like saying Ariel Sharon is much better than Hitler because he had not killed as many innocents (yet).
In truth a democratic goverment should reflect the will and intentions of the people who are represented by that government. That says to me more about America at the moment. I pray that the next US elections prove me wrong!
KALSOOM HUSSAIN, U.K -
wrote on 6/2/2004 5:05:43 PM
Comment: salaams.I have to say that the aricle was writen in a very honest and straight from the heart manner. However, i believe that it was very narrow-minded, unintentionally though. What i would like to know is WHY did the senate even have to VOTE that the abuse should be condemned. Does such a disgusting, inhumane act need to be condemned?- surely more needs to be done about this than people voting to condemn it. After all it's actions that speak louder than words. Bush may have condemned it but he didn't apologise did he? Instead it was his colleagues. Muslims DO need to be united but Inshallah when they do, that is the time when Americans won't be putting up a fake show for definite.
John, USA -
wrote on 5/28/2004 7:12:00 PM
Comment: Well done,especially for making use of so much diverse data. But don't think these issues are over.
Maryam Arinola Alege, Lagos, Nigeria -
wrote on 5/28/2004 6:11:04 AM
Comment: Asalam alaykun, much as I would have wished for this article to be a true reflection of what is going through the mind of Americans concerning the torture and the infamous wars that are being waged against the Muslims all over the world today,but No. Mujhaid a prolivic writer though, miss some salient points here. America under President Bush needs much more to apease the Muslim world than mere open condemnations and bringing the few to "Justice". Let them not see us (Muslims) as Jews under Hitler who must be eliminated on the face of the earth because our idealogies are not the same. Let them stop the hatred right from their own soil. That way, any American Soldier that is sent to fight where ever, would do it with human face.America has to stop this carnage, enough is enough because Muslims all over the world are not better off for it. It is our own Brothers and Sisters who are being Killed, Tortured, Displaced, Despised and Incacerated on daily basis. Maa Salam.
sara, us -
wrote on 5/26/2004 8:59:51 PM
Comment: well put! I would like to see the same response re the torture and abuse of political prisoners which is an open secret among "muslim" dictators, kings, and tyrants...
Mark, London -
wrote on 5/21/2004 10:57:43 AM
Comment: Good article! But, I am amazed by some of the reactions that I've seen or read in the Media, comment such as "They want to make it clear that these are isolated cases and America is not like that" as mentioned in this article. Well how can this be so? Considering the continuing abuses in Afghanistan (see www.hrw.org) and also in the concentration camp in Cuba, and previously on file what was done in Vietnam. I find that this is "institutionalised" torture may be more than just isolated cases.
|Search The Quran|
|Something to Ask...|
|I seek the forgiveness of Allah, there is no true god except Allah, the Ever-Living, the Self-Subsisting, and I turn to Him in repentance.|