1-800-432-4262
  News | Education | Halal & healthy | Parenting | Teens | Kids | Marriage | The Quran | Glossary 
Audio Video Computer Books Gifts & Things Games


Rate this Article

In The Shade of the Quran Vol 10

$22.50
Buy Now


Islamic Books > Children's > The Seafaring Beggar and Other Tales

$6.95 $4.25
Buy Now


Islamic CDs > Children's Songs > Dawud Wharnsby Ali > Sunshine, Dust and the Messenger (CD)

$12.95
Buy Now

IT MAY BE ZABIHA, BUT IS IT HALAL?

Before you sink your teeth into the next Zabiha slaughtered meat product, ask yourself: is it Halal?

This is a question most Muslims don't think to ask, according to Ahmad Sakr, professor emeritus of Food Science and author of "Understanding Halal Food" and "A Muslim Guide to Food Ingredients" in an interview with Sound Vision from his California home.

The issue of Halal meat has been a bone of contention amongst North American Muslim communities.

Some Muslims argue that the meat of the Jews and Christians is Halal for Muslims. Others say the meat must be slaughtered according to Islamic rites for it to be fit for Muslim consumption.

Both groups can find support from legal opinions given by Islamic scholars.

But what's often ignored is that regardless of whether you choose to eat Zabiha or not, the meat of the animal itself may not be Halal, says Sakr.

THE USE OF ELECTRIC SHOCK ON ANIMALS

With regards to meat that is not slaughtered according to Islamic rites, Sakr says it is not Halal because of the effect electric shock on blood drainage.

He explains that in regular meat slaughterhouses, animals are brought into an alley and given an electric shock to the head to make them unconscious.

The animal's legs are then tied up and it is hung upside down. A knife is put to its neck,and then it is slaughtered. The animal is then temporarily left alone to allow the blood to drain from its body. From there, the meat is processed.

But using electric shock, explains Sakr, means that all of the animal's blood does not leave its body, because electric shock affects the central nervous system.

On the contrary, if an animal is slaughtered in accordance with Islamic guidelines, the central nervous system works properly, and all of the animal's blood comes out.

Remaining blood in the animal is a source of fermentation and destruction of meat quality. This means bacteria can grow easily on the meat.

From an Islamic perspective, Sakr says it is Haram to eat meat containing blood, as it is clearly stated in the Quran that Muslims cannot consume blood.

THE CONDITIONS OF HALAL

"Halal is Halal if the following conditions are taken into consideration," explains Sakr.

The first is that the animal is itself is Halal. That means no pork, for instance.

The second, is that the food the animal consumes does not contain any blood or meat. Sakr explains that the animal has to be herbivorous to be Halal, and adds that an animal becomes Haram if it consumes blood and /or meat.

"Islam dictates that if an animal has received meat and/or blood while it was Halal, it becomes Haram and in order to become Halal you have to put that animal in a quarantine area for 40 days before you slaughter it to make it Halal," says Sakr.

If this is not respected, "that animal will contain the disease called Mad Cow Disease," he says. (You can read more about mad cow disease at its official site at http://www.mad-cow.org/)

The third condition Sakr lists for an animal to be Halal is that it should not be given any hormones.

In the meat industry, he says beef is given female sex hormones. This is meant to increase the weight of the animal in a short period of time.

The effect of consuming an animal with injected female hormones is a reduction in the masculine appearance of boys and men. It also reduces sexual appetite, explains Sakr, adding that this of course would not happen by eating just one meal containing meat. Rather, it can result when people are consuming meat daily, and Sakr mentioned "KFC and and MacDonald's" as two examples.

But eaters of Zabiha meat should not get on a high horse either: even if an animal is slaughtered in the Islamic manner, it will still contain these hormones.

PRESERVATIVES ADD TO THE LETHAL MEAT MIX

Sakr points out that the meat industry also puts the preservatives nitrite or nitrate in meat. These react with the amino group of amino acids of the meat or protein to produce nitroso-amine. This is red pigment.

This results in meat still looking red in its color, as if it is fresh, even if it has been on the shelf for one or two weeks. While this may be good for industry, it causes cancer.

Animal food containing meat and blood, as well as dangerous hormones and preservatives lead Sakr to conclude one thing.

"If that animal has been fed all of the above, then it is no longer Halal, even if a Muslim goes to the farm and slaughters the animal in the name of Allah, [it] does not make the animal Halal."

HORMONES IN MILK TOO

In February 1994, the United States Food and Drug Administration (USDA) approved the use of another hormone for cows-estrogen. This was used to increase milk bladder size and milk excretion resulting in greater production of milk in a shorter period of time.

Estrogen can cause cancer of the breast and other cancers in general.

This is particularly frightening when we consider that many people drink milk daily, and consume its byproducts like milk, cheese and cookies.

While the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) demanded that farms put the label EST on milk cartons if they use estrogen on cows, the milk industry convinced the FDA to forego putting this label. That means you don't know if the milk you drink contains estrogen or not.

THE SOLUTION: MUSLIMS RUNNING MORE FARMS

The only viable solution, according to Sakr, is to establish farms which will be run by Muslims who will raise animals feeding them only plants, no hormones, preservatives or meat and blood.

He looks to the next generation of Muslims in North America to do that, though. Sakr points out that "most of the immigrant Muslims who came to Canada and the United States are highly educated and their impression about a farmer in their old countries, [is] that he is poor and uneducated, while we are educated."

In contrast, Sakr notes that in Canada and the US, Americans and Canadians may have a Ph.D. in animal sciences, for instance, but may still do farm work and not consider a lower class job.

CONSIDER SOME FORM OF VEGETARIANISM

Another option is simply eating a vegetable-based diet, as opposed to a meat based one. While Islam has not forbidden meat eating, it also has not made it a religious requirement to consume meat on a daily basis. Moderation in eating, as is the case with other aspects of life, is the key, according to Islam.

By opting for a more vegetable-based diet, this will reduce the meat intake of individuals, and lessen the amount of hormones and other dangerous chemicals ingested indirectly because of the meat.

Current science and health research has also found eating a vegetarian diet can be healthier for you.

EATING ORGANIC FOODS

Meat, dairy products and eggs that are from animals which have been fed with organic food is also an option for those who want to keep eating meat.

Organic livestock are not given antibiotics or hormones. They are given products that have been derived from natural sources.

While organic foods may be more expensive than meat bought at the supermarket, the fact that it's free of cancer-causing ingredients is well worth the cost if you want to maintain your meat-eating.

According to the Organic Farming Research Foundation based in Santa Cruz, California, about one percent of the US food supply is grown using organic methods. In 1996, this represented over $3.5 billion in retail sales.

Organic foods can be bought at natural foods stores, the health food sections and produce departments of supermarkets and at farmers' markets.


EATING HALAL AND HEALTHY
A New Page on Halal and Healthy
What Fast Food is Halal to Eat
Health Guidelines From Quran and Sunnah
Non Muslim Halal Business: the Al Safa update

Kosher Labeling: How it Works
The Untouchable Milk
Animals fed animals: Are they halal? Hormones etc.
Homeless Kids on Capitol Hill
Defend the Food Stamp Program
Discuss Your thoughts in the Forum: HALAL & HEALTHY
Ask the Muslim Halal Expert: Mazhar Husaini


Your Comments

Sue Rabinovich, New Jersey - wrote on 5/18/2005 7:05:03 AM
Rating: Rating

Comment: Great article. I dont think the answer is in becoming vegetarian. We need the protein...and I like the taste of meat :)


Ayman, Toronto - wrote on 3/13/2005 11:21:26 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: great article, I advice every muslim and non muslim though to read it...


farrah, UK - wrote on 11/27/2004 10:22:29 AM
Rating: Rating

Comment: Ive read about this topic before, the article was put together very well, maybe the author should write a book!!. Although I think it makes one assume that eating no poultry or being a vegetarian is healthy ! - which is not the case for someone who is not fit and healthy - considering protien is very important for those who dont want to eat nuts and lentils which also contain carbs and fats or those that have special diets, with less intake of sugar or carbs. Btw, does anyone know of a UK supplier of organic poultry and meat?


saima nadeem, fortville,IN - wrote on 10/16/2004 11:53:37 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: A very eye-opening article!I hope a lot of muslims will insha'llah benefit from it.I had a lot of arguments with many of my friends in this regard,and nobody was able to convince me as to whether "zabeha"or"halal" fall into the category of allowed meat-eating.I just wonder the veggies we eat are not exposed to any form of haram ingredient?? thanks.


s, california - wrote on 12/1/2003 9:15:19 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: Our halal butcher here buys meat from a local organic farm which they have arranged to have a muslim butcher go out to slaughter the organic chicken in a halal way. Great example of cooperation between communities!


Ghassan Adi D.V.M., Oakville, Ontario - wrote on 10/2/2003 9:06:22 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: I would advise Muslims to start a Co-operation business to produce Halal meat in each region of North America to produce Halal food for our community. please have a look at the following article: http://www.islamonline.net/iol-english/dowalia/techng-2000-oct-07/techng3.asp Ghassan ghassan@sprint.ca


Khalid, London - wrote on 6/17/2003 7:57:19 AM
Rating: Rating

Comment: There is no legitimate difference of opinion on the question of whether the meat of the people of the book is allowed or not. Firstly "Christians" don't slaughter their meat in the name of God, so it is definitely haram. Secondly Jewish Kosher meat is allowed (as far as I know), but we should only eat it if we have no alternative (i.e. halal meat is unavailable). Apart from that error it is an excellent article exposing the fallacies of "Halal" meat. As someone who is chronicaly ill, I have to be very careful about my diet. Unfotunately I have little choice but to eat "Halal" meat which is infested with hormones, anti-biotics, pathogens, and only Allah knows what else. There was an excellent BBC documentary (Panorama) on the European meat industry recently. It showed undercover footage of European meat processors injecting pork protein into Beef and Chicken (pork is cheaper). Apparently this is legal (although they have to say on the label - but they don't , which is illegal). These alien proteins are only detectable using expensive DNA tests. More worryingly still these companies have managed to destroy the genetic information in the injected proteins so they are no longer identifiable as coming from Pig, Cow or whatever. - i.e. there is no test which will detect whether or not your halal meat has been laced with pork. I think the final piece of advice is sadly the best - to reduce the amount of meat we eat. Certainly our ancestors ate a lot less meat. There is nothing in islam which forbids a person eating a largely/wholly vegetarian diet - as long as it is not for moral reasons. As muslims we believe in the killing and eating of animals - as long as it is done in the name of God and according to his Shariah. Can you honestly say that the meat that you are eating passes this criterion? I can't. May Allah forgive us and guide us towards the Truth.


Fahmi, Chicago - wrote on 6/7/2003 7:24:36 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: Alhamdulillah. that's is a great answer . even though i feel unhappy to hear that because i feel it's too hard to follow your method, but i will try my best . i don't have a choice to avoid it i've to follow it. thank's


Mohamed, Rahman - wrote on 3/3/2003 8:14:27 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: Alhamdullillah. I am finding the answers to my questions.


Carrie, Hawaii - wrote on 2/15/2003 5:26:21 PM
Rating: Rating

Comment: Very informative and interesting. Stunning due to the fact that most of the population in Canada and U.S. A. are 'oblivious' to the deleterious effects of the food stuffs we put into our bodies in the name of nutrition and health, all under the 'concerned and caring' eye of the government and its governing industries. How do we spread the word more effectively? Thanx


More Comments


   
Cart
FREE Newsletter

Loaded with Valuable Deals & Content!

 Name:
 
 Email:
 
 Be the FIRST to receive: FRESH Perspectives, Helpful Tips & Exclusive Product Offers!

 Preferred mail format:
  auto-detect
  text  HTML
 
Search
Articles Products
Search The Quran
YusufAli Pickthall
Surah Ayah
Something to Ask...
O Allah!
I ask You by every name that You have, that You have called Yourself by, that You have taught any of Your Creation, that You have revealed in Your Book, or that You may have kept secret with Yourself.
Make the Quran the spring of my heart, the light of my breast, the dispeller of my sorrows, the eraser of my anxieties and worries.
RadioIslam.com
  News | Education | Halal & healthy | Parenting | Teens | Kids | Marriage | The Quran | Glossary 
Copyright © 2009 Sound Vision Foundation, Inc. All rights reserved worldwide.
9058 S Harlem Ave, Bridgeview, IL 60455, USA
Email: info@soundvision.com · Phone: 708.430.1255 · Fax: 708.430.1346
Last update: